wheat field

Conflicting Realities, or in other words, Thanksgiving Dinner Conversation

Posted by
mesas, Utah
Where do you focus? On the near mesas or mesas or those in the distance? What if you’re talking to someone can only focus on the trees?

Everyone has their own way of looking at a life, and we rarely see the same thing when we view the same situation. Where one person will see a bland picture, another will see it differently, finding beauty. Who we are affects what we see.

The NRA sees gun ownership as essential to freedom and safety; others see gun control as essential to peace and harmony. Who is right? It depends on your perspective; in some ways they both are. But when we have to share space with someone with a vastly different viewpoint of everything, it seems like we are in totally different realities. How do we handle it?

I’ve seen several different ways: fight them, join them, or maintain our space. For example, I had a friend whose mother had dementia. She constantly sought to return her mother to the way of life that they shared, helping her to recall people she once loved and things that had been important to her most of her life. Piece by piece, the illness overcame her until she no longer remembered how to maintain life. But the daughter struggled and worked constantly to keep her mother in this reality as much as she could.

spider, spider web
Some conversationalists wait like a spider for you to fall into their web of argument. Are you willing?

Another friend’s father has Alzheimer’s and she makes no attempt to keep him in this reality. Looking around his care home, he often thinks he’s working at the bank. Rather than explain that he is in a nursing facility, she talks to him as if she works at the bank too or is a customer. When he tries to leave, she talks about staying until closing time. He understands, stops trying to elope the facility, and quickly forgets his desire to leave. She chose to join her father in whatever reality he was in.

When the situation is less extreme, and we’re talking holiday visits with family members that we don’t relate to, I’ve seen a few people who are able to maintain their own reality without accepting the other person’s point of view, to keep the peace. Is it comfortable? Not exactly, but it may be far more comfortable than arguing about conflicting ways of life, politics, or religion. When the relatives talk about a vastly different political agenda, it’s hard, but I can choose not to join in. If the group is large enough, I can (and sometimes do) read my cell phone or begin a conversation with someone else. I can check out of their zealous diatribe without challenging it or arguing. If they want to find a shared conversation, they can change the subject. Sometimes I just state, “let’s agree to disagree” and suggest that we move to a new topic. I don’t need to convince anyone that their way is wrong and my way is right. We can co-exist while being different.

spider, spider web
Carefully constructed lair

Sometimes I can vastly disagree with someone’s decision, but not argue about it. It isn’t any of my business, and I have no right to ask them to change their life to match my point of view. I can allow them to be who they are while I am different. It can be tiring, but I can no longer enter someone else’s reality that doesn’t match my way of life. I am finally wise enough to see that they can’t join me in a different point of view, either. I can’t believe how long it has taken me to get here.

wheat field
Where is your focus? On the wheat, road, or mountains?


  1. I like hearing other people’s perspectives on things, it broadens my understanding and sometimes changes my views if it makes more sense. But I enjoy an exchange of ideas, not an “I’m-right-no-one-else-is” lecture. Usually in those situations, I just say “Well, everyone has a right to their opinion.” They don’t always agree about that, of course, but then I just back out of the conversation.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I hear you sister! And I can’t believe how long it has taken me to get here either. The fabulous thing is, I am here now and I love the wide open space and feeling of vulnerability that it gives me. No more feeling tired!

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I usually am passive and leave things be. I agree with you that one is probably not going to change views over Thanksgiving dinner. 🙂 But I like to think I can argue/present rational thoughts when there is a challenge to be met. When something is said that is simply not true, I don’t hesitate to step up to the plate.
    And at rare times I do encounter people who really enjoy the back and forth. We respectfully attack the ideas and not the person. 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s